Tuesday, January 7, 2020

2019 - IN REVIEW: MOST OVERRATED

 
US

There is a lot of good in “Us”, director Jordan Peele's follow-up to his successful horror film, “Get Out”, but it is also a film that has a myriad of problems that I cannot help but think it is not as worthy for all the critical praise that it gets.

The film is about a young family who have their holiday interrupted and threatened when their doppelgangers arrive and attempt to take their place. For the first half of the film, it is a wonderfully creepy experience filled with some chilling images and situations. The doppelganger concept is a favourite of mine, and I believe it is one that works incredibly well in horror films. Being stalked and chased by someone who looks exactly like you is such a strong visual, that is also just horrific. “Us” is excellent in creating an uneasy atmosphere when the doubles arrive and at sustaining an intensity when the two families share an extended stand off together. All of the family members also play their doppelganger variants but it is actress Lupita Nyong'o who stands out above the pack for her stunning performance as Red, the evil double of Adelaide. She makes two distinct characters out of Red and Adelaide and they couldn't be more different. Scenes when she is playing against herself are just something else, and the reason why “Us” works as well as it does rests entirely on her shoulders.

Another aspect of the film that works well is the non-traditional and very bizarre musical score from Michael Abels. It kind of sounds like carnival music being played in a broken music box, but it works so well and is so creepy. It perfectly suited the equally impressive horror visuals captured by cinematographer Mike Gioulakis. This is a seriously good looking horror film and I was surprised by how dark the film was, meaning how deep the blacks were in the imposing shadows.

As the film goes along, it starts to become obvious that this doppelganger phenomenon isn't happening to just this one family and that everyone's double is out to claim their place in the world. Somewhere along the line, we find out that these doubles are called “the tethered” and it is here that Jordan Peele starts to make some rather big mistakes in his screenplay. By explicitly explaining who the tethered are and how they came to be, the mystery and creep factor is lost and the film begins to drastically fall apart. I get that by doing so, it makes the “message” of the film easier to understand, but it also works against the film as a whole and frankly turns it into a bit of a ridiculous mess. “Us” would have been so much more powerful if Peele trusted his audience and didn't feel the need to explain every detail. Sometimes it works better in horror films if things aren't ever explained “why”, and to me this is the biggest failing in “Us”. However, because of the message that the film is trying to convey, (which is that the lower income and homeless families, not to mention those that are minorities of race, that the US consider their dirty little secret and have tried to sweep under the carpet, have had enough and want to stand up to be heard and counted...ie. They are human too and want their say), I feel that reviewers have over-praised “Us” and neglected to look more closely at its failings. These failings are huge as once we know the truth of the tethered, the reality of the situation does not work. You cannot help but question what would happen to the tethered if certain other things happened to their human double; the explanation just does not work, which means neither does the film. Also if anyone was surprised by the film's final twist, then they just have not watched enough horror movies, as this was anything other than a surprise.

I understand that the above paragraph my not be the greatest, but I am trying to be considerate of spoilers for those who have yet to see the film. Let me just say that for the first half of “Us”, it is an excellent and chilling horror film. It is beautifully shot and scored particularly well, however when it begins to explain exactly what the deal is in regards to the film's antagonists, it falls apart dramatically, and never recovers. The reason why I believe the film is overrated is due to the fact that reviewers are sensitive to the message “Us” is trying to project, and as such are praising it wholeheartedly due to that message rather than critiquing the film for its very obvious narrative failings. Don't get me wrong, I do like “Us” but it is definitely overrated. 

 

Monday, January 6, 2020

2019 - IN REVIEW: BIGGEST SURPRISE


DUMBO

I am a massive Tim Burton fan to the point that I am sure many people could accuse me of being an apologist for this great director. Most people these days feel that Burton has lost his touch and becoming a caricature of his himself, but I can genuinely say with hand on heart that I have enjoyed all of Burton's recent features that have been poorly received. Even when the films aren't the greatest, there is always something that I really enjoy in them (“Dark Shadows” is the perfect example of this). However, very early on during the production of “Miss Peregrine's Home For Peculiar Children”, when it was announced that Burton's following film would be a live-action remake of “Dumbo”, I must admit I was livid, and thought it was a waste of his talents and a terrible idea altogether. In my mind, I just could not see how they could make the animated classic from 1941 work as a live-action film. For one of the first times in my life, I was not looking forward to a Tim Burton film.

Cut to a year or so later when the film's teaser trailer was released and after watching it, I thought that maybe this wasn't going to be as bad as I expected, although admittedly there still wasn't a huge lot to go on. Then when the film was released, so too came the (predictably) negative reviews. The film was soulless, a travesty to the original, Burton has lost his magic, blah blah blah. Honestly, in this day and age it almost appears chic to attack a Tim Burton film in a review, but I am ashamed to admit that these reviews did affect my own will to rush out and see the film. It was about two weeks after it had been released that I decided that I really should make the effort to see “Dumbo” on the big screen, so made my way out to do so. The cinema was fairly bare, almost as a precursor of what was to come, as it appeared no one was too interested in the film. The film began and to my surprise I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT!!! Seriously, I was blown away by Tim Burton's version of “Dumbo” and loved (almost) everything about it.

The parts of the original film that I could not get my head around working in a live-action film, such as all of the talking animals, Burton did away with. Gone are the talking storks, elephants and mice, but beautifully, Burton does make reference to them all. Even that weird looking train, “Casey Jnr.”, from the animated film is referenced in the train's design here, which brought a smile to my face. One of the greatest moments of this remake is when Burton also finds a way to make reference to the truly bizarre “Pink Elephants on Parade” scene, that occurs in the original when Dumbo is drunk. It is such an odd scene in the animated film that I was sure that it would not be retained here, but Burton came up with the most magnificent way to include it. One of the biggest aspects in regards to the 1941 film that Burton and his team had to overcome with their version was it's short running time. At only sixty four minutes long, the story is far too short to pad out and stretch to feature length and still make it work. As such, this new version follows the original story for the first hour before branching off on its own where Dumbo is sold as the attraction of a new and very large theme park, before he then sets off to find his mother who he is separated from earlier in the film. For mine, all of this new material works wonderfully well and fits with the first, more familiar hour of the film. While the film is rated PG, the second half goes to some quite dark places but with Burton behind the wheel, this is really no surprise.

One aspect of the film where Tim Burton excelled at is in his casting. Nearly everyone is fantastic here, with Danny DeVito being the absolute stand out playing the kind-hearted ringmaster of the circus. It is the first time DeVito and Burton have worked together since “Big Fish” from 2003, and as great as he was as The Penguin in “Batman Returns”, I think I would have to say that his performance here is his best in a Burton film yet. The reunions don't stop there though as Michael Keaton appears for the first time in a Burton film since 1992, the aforementioned Batman sequel being the last time the two worked together. Sadly though, it is his performance that is the only thing that I do not love about “Dumbo”. It is not that he is bad per se, but it screams caricature rather than character; his character never rang true for me. Eva Green was delightful as the elegant trapeze artist, while Colin Farrell oozed charm as the children's father and a war veteran who lost his arm in battle. Speaking of the children, both Finley Hobbins and Nico Parker are great in their roles (and thankfully never annoying, like kids can be in movies), with Parker the spitting image of her mother, Thandie Newton.

Now onto Dumbo himself, and I am delighted to say that I just fell in love with his design. He is obviously a full cgi creation, but the animators have given the elephant so much character and big beautiful eyes, that you cannot help but feel for this creature's plight. Amazingly, he fits perfectly into the world and you believe he is there amongst the actors. While his mother has been designed more as a photo-realistic elephant, Dumbo himself is slightly exaggerated in areas, but it just works so well. He feels alive, and you just care for him so much. The little fella is just so damned cute!

Behind the scenes, and once again Tim Burton has created another stunningly good looking film with “Dumbo”. This time around he has used Ben Davis as his cinematographer, and the pair have created gorgeous images leaning towards a lot of blues and reds. Burton's regular composer, Danny Elfman, has come up with one of his best scores yet here and there were moments during the film, like when Dumbo takes flight, when the music just takes over and the whole thing becomes sublime. Man, I love this film.

I could honestly talk about this film for ages, but what must be apparent by now is that Tim Burton's “Dumbo” will feature in my Top Twenty of 2019, so I should leave some things to talk about there. Suffice to say, I was very pleasantly surprised by just how much I ended up adoring “Dumbo”. It is such a great, and beautiful family film, and I also consider it Burton's best film since 2007's “Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street”, something I never anticipated when the film was first announced.


2019 - IN REVIEW: BIGGEST DISAPPOINTMENT


DOMINO

As much as it pains me to say it, there was no greater cinematic disappointment this year than Brian De Palma's latest film “Domino”. It certainly wasn't the worst film that I saw in 2019, but what made it so disappointing was the missed opportunity, the what it could have been. The shooting of the film was filled with problems due largely to Dutch producers incorrectly claiming they had the funds to make the film, and then clamouring on a daily basis to find the cash to keep the production going. De Palma himself stated that the making of “Domino” was one of the most unpleasant of his entire career, largely due to being stuck inside hotel rooms waiting, instead of being able to shoot the film he wanted and agreed to make. Out of the proposed one hundred day shoot, De Palma and his crew were only able to shoot on thirty of those days until the project was shut down. Amazingly from what little they had shot, they were able to make a movie that could be released to the public. While the resulting 89 minute film that ended up being released was “De Palma's cut”, make no mistake that the end result is NOT the film that De Palma had initially envisioned when signing on to the project.

Now going into watching “Domino” I was aware of all the above, so surely that tempered my expectations a little? Well yes, that is true, however Brian De Palma is my favourite director (tied with Martin Scorsese and David Lynch) working today and sadly the length in between each of his features is getting longer and longer (between “Domino” and his previous film, “Passion”, was a wait of seven years). Not to mention that this great director will turn eighty later this year, so there is a real fear that each new film could be his last, so even though I knew “Domino” was going to have problems, I could not help but get excited about a new film from Brian De Palma. While my expectations had been lowered, what raised them again was when the webmaster from “De Palma a la Mod” posted an early positive review of “Domino”. I thought this is a guy who knows and loves De Palma so there was a fair chance his opinion would reflect my own, so I once again went into “Domino” with high expectations. At the end of the day, it is not one of Brian De Palma's greatest films, but it also isn't the total disaster it could've (and let's face it, probably should've) been. In saying that, my initial viewing of the film was not a good one. Whilst I loved the opening rooftop chase, the rest of the film I hated. Once I finished it, I actually messaged one of my friends and told them that the film was a piece of shit! However, with my expectations now gone, my second viewing of “Domino” was a much, much better experience. I found a lot more to like about it and ended up enjoying it a fair bit. Pino Donaggio's score is very good and atmospheric, Nikolaj Coster-Waldau gives a good performance as Christian, the film's protagonist, and the aforementioned rooftop chase is almost classic De Palma. Much has been made about two other set pieces; the slow-motion ending and the “red carpet” scene, and while I agree that they are highlights of “this” film, I still think that they both could've been better handled, so am not as gung-ho about them as others. Sadly, where the film falls down is in the main story itself which moves by very quickly to the point that it feels like a cliffs note version (for obvious reasons), and as lovely as Carice Van Houten is, her character has nothing to do and is no doubt a victim of the revised shooting schedule of the film's making. Speaking of the story, “Domino” is about a cop from Copenhagen who stumbles upon a terrorist cell and must attempt to track them down before they fulfil a planned attack. What is interesting is that De Palma focuses a lot on the way the terrorists film and edit their propaganda videos and the way they are then presented to the public to sell their message and image.

While I can now sit down and watch “Domino” and enjoy it for what it is, make no mistake that it is a crushing disappointment compared to what should have been. When comparing this new film to one of the De Palma classics, such as “Dressed to Kill” or “Blow Out”, there really is no comparison as “Domino” pales to them. However there is enough in the film to see that Brian De Palma still has it, and that is the film we should have got had the potential to be so much greater, which is ultimately the most disappointing aspect of the whole thing. Especially in a year when another of the ageing “Brat Pack”, Martin Scorsese, delivered one of his best film's with “The Irishman”, it was sad to see his contemporary at the other end of the scale with “Domino”. Yes, I can enjoy the film, but it is still my biggest disappointment of 2019, and I just hope that it is not the film that Brian De Palma bows out on. I hope this great director, like Scorsese, can give his fans one more classic. He certainly still has the ability, it is just whether or not he is given the opportunity to do so.